I’ve seen Elementary fans claiming their Sherlock is better than Sherlock’s because ours is an asshole and theirs is ‘sympathetic’ and ‘kind’.
I have nothing against Elementary, but may I just remind you - Sherlock is an asshole, because Sherlock is canonically an asshole. He was described as being cold, dispassionate and arrogant - not kind.
oh dear.
From ‘The Adventure of the Three Garridebs’, when Watson is shot: “For the first time, I had a glimpse of a great heart as well as a great brain.”
From ‘The Adventure of the Six Napoleons’, when Lestrade pays Holmes a sincere and heartfelt compliment : “And as he turned away, it seemed he was more nearly moved by the softer human emotions than I had ever seen him.”
From ‘The Problem of Thor Bridge’, when a rich client explains how he tried to seduce his children’s governess: “this young lady was in a sense under your protection…you have tried to ruin a defenseless girl who was under your roof. Some of you rich men have to be taught that all the world cannot be bribed into condoning your offenses.”
From ‘The Adventure of the Veiled Lodger’, after hearing the tragic story of a woman whose face was mauled by a lion; “Then Holmes stretched out his long arm and patted her hand with such a show of sympathy as I had seldom known him to exhibit, ‘Poor girl!’ he said, ‘Poor girl! The ways of fate are indeed hard to understand. If there is not some compensation hereafter, then the world is a cruel jest’ “
From ‘The Adventure of the Speckled Band’, when speaking with a client whose father is physically abusive: “Five little livid spots, the marks of four fingers and a thumb, were printed upon the white wrist. ‘You have been cruelly used,’ said Holmes.”
Also, in “The Adventure of Abbey Grange,” he helps a young man escape, who intervened to prevent an alcoholic aristocrat from beating his wife.
In “The Adventure of the Second Stain”, Holmes goes out of his way to shield Lady Hilda from her husband’s anger, even though the husband was Holmes’ client.
In “The Adventure of the Blue Carbuncle” he lets a pathetic petty criminal go free because he doesn’t think making him a ‘jailbird’ will help.
There are many other instances of Holmes showing kindness, empathy and even breaking the law to help people gain justice.
Other phrases and words Watson uses to describe Holmes at various times:
“quiet, genial.”
“without a harshness, which was foreign to his nature.”
“he had a remarkable gentleness and courtesy in his dealings with women.”
Holmes may have displayed a certain impatience for social affectation, but he maintains a strong moral compass and asserts this fact several times, in various situations, towards various people.
This idea that Holmes is a “sociopathic” asshole is quite a contemporary reading and, might I add, a lazy one that’s as ignorant of mental illness as it is offensive to those of us who’re tired of white men getting to stomp all over people in the name of ‘genius’ and ‘anti-hero’ status. BBC Sherlock’s reading of Holmes is one that’s built on popular cultural tropes, and succeeds because of it. ‘Elementary’ reads Holmes with a fuller attention to the complexities of his character.
Anytime someone says ‘well Holmes is an asshole’ as a conclusive fact, I know that your canon knowledge is either limited or deliberately misinterpreted.
Do some re-reading.
somebody grab a garnish, u just got served
(Source: seanprouvaire, via kogiopsis)
lazybiochemistryfrogshands liked this tarragonthedragon liked this
soundsfaebutokay reblogged this from angelofgrace96 solvingpuzzles-savingtheday reblogged this from kindaoffkilter
kilterstreet liked this
getsherlock221b liked this
fullhideoutdragon reblogged this from irresistible-revolution
notacolorfullesbian liked this
boredom00111000 reblogged this from aphonicdreams
bookshistoryspacelover liked this
katyuni liked this shaun-lara liked this
angelyrics liked this
angelbud liked this
batbeech reblogged this from thehumantrampoline
batbeech liked this fingertipkindoflove liked this
lesbianfightclub reblogged this from thehumantrampoline
lesbianfightclub liked this queergeologist liked this
tontontonberry reblogged this from kweh-not-wark
tontontonberry liked this
kweh-not-wark reblogged this from levynite yomawari liked this
hetvankarsa reblogged this from captainlordauditor
kireikiru reblogged this from omahdon el-jarado liked this
allaboardthecringe reblogged this from ultraericthered and added: Remember when the Great Mouse Detective had Basil get shocked right in the middle of playing music when Olivia mentioned...
gritsandbrits liked this
macconmidhe liked this lifeisinfinitelystranger liked this
shes-a-writer11924 liked this
mizzchevious liked this
enter-the-bogman liked this yusufalkasayni reblogged this from ronmiones
2030kamenriders liked this
autisticassassinbird reblogged this from aimmyarrowshigh sincerevioletdragonfly reblogged this from thecookiemonster77
lilac-rabbits reblogged this from aikotters digitalash-inadigitalurn liked this
aikotters reblogged this from thecookiemonster77 benjaminthesnail liked this
smoke-and-statues reblogged this from mrevaunit42
smoke-and-statues liked this dragonmarquise reblogged this from omahdon
soilrockslove liked this
herehavesomefandomspam liked this
seanprouvaire posted this - Show more notes


