I came to the conclusion that most people in America would really like to be able to get a job where they think they’re doing something noble and nice and good and it isn’t just for the money. But the reason they hate what they call the cultural elite is that they see it as a class that’s grabbed all the jobs where you can get paid to do something that isn’t just for the money—if it’s art, if it’s charity, if it’s intellectual, if it’s political, whatever it might be. Because those are all the things where, if you want to get a job in that area, they won’t pay you for the first year or two, because there are all those unpaid internships. They see these people who grab all the jobs where you get to be good and noble. And we don’t get to do that. If your father is an air-conditioner repairman from Nebraska, its conceivable that you might become a CEO, but you can’t imagine being the drama critic for the New York Times. So if you come from a background like that and you want to actually have a career which involves doing something noble in the world, what can you do? You can join the army. That’s about it. Or you can work for the church. That explains a lot of the focus of right-wing populism. The right wing figured that out, that people want enough to survive and to do good.
—
David Graeber, “Beholden”, Guernica (via varanine)
I think teaching is one way to do this without having to go the unpaid intern route. Maybe teaching is too unforgiving, though. Or perhaps it doesn’t allow for enough upward mobility?
(via snagamat)
I dunno, I wouldn’t see being a drama critic for the New York Times as something ‘noble and nice and good’, I’d see it as something pretentious and pointless. On the other hand, teaching, medical careers (including nursing), social workers, even law enforcement - all seem (potentially) very noble. But I think they’re not mentioned because, with the exception of some medical professionals, they won’t gain you lots of money and they all involve a lot of work. I feel like the fact that this guy can only imagine having a well paid and prestigious job as ‘doing something that isn’t just for the money’ somehow illustrates how out of touch Occupy ‘intellectuals’ are with people who are not pretentious / middle class well off ‘intellectuals’ - which is (I think) one of the main reasons why the whole ‘movement’ failed miserably.
(via andyispoesizing)
this is bullshit. like, this is the point where economically secure white liberals show themselves to basically be the same as economically secure conservatives. “people hate us because they wish they were good and noble like us.” forreal doe?
yup, fuck occupy.
(via so-treu)
Call me crazy, but I always figured at least part of the reason why so many people from lower socio-economic backgrounds in the US end up in the armed forces is because it’s the simplest, most feasible way to get free education and health insurance, plus a paycheck your family can actually sorta live on. That doesn’t diminish the nobility of service, if you want to call it that, but being in a position to join the army *without* having to think pragmatically about the medical, scholastic and economic benefits strikes me as being a form of privilege.
(Source: guernicamag.com, via karnythia)
moonagedaydream liked this
neo-phobe-blog liked this
digitalcollecting liked this aseismic liked this
la-monja liked this
gibiskwad liked this
girlinternet liked this
silkstones liked this
murooned liked this
claritzajimenez liked this
gerikson reblogged this from guardiancomment
torukun1 liked this
ejmedina-blog liked this kaijuvsgiantrobotsvsme liked this
happilyunorthodox liked this
doskapozora liked this
fozmeadows reblogged this from karnythia
artisansoulleader liked this
decodeunzipdiscover reblogged this from karnythia
decodeunzipdiscover liked this
johnboyaeger liked this
caoimhinkellehers reblogged this from karnythia kiskidee reblogged this from karnythia
eshusplayground liked this
nomoretexasgovernorsforpresident liked this
karnythia reblogged this from so-treu
f-wonderland liked this
dionysustaint reblogged this from so-treu
so-treu reblogged this from ziatroyano
f1ghtoffyourdem0ns liked this
ziatroyano reblogged this from guardiancomment
dizzynwizzy reblogged this from guardiancomment foxlot posted this
- Show more notes