superanchorzombie-blog-blog asked: I've been thinking about it and I guess if you assume angels can intentionally bring people back soulless (and not just when Castiel failed at retrieving Sam's soul) I don't see anything saying your Adam theory is impossible. I just don't understand, though, why the show would have Death lying to Dean and those fangirls being wrong and just never clue the audience in to that. Even if the Jimmy dead thing is supposed to be a clue it's hardly confirming he was brought back soulless by Michael.
Honestly, I think it makes about as much sense as going four whole seasons without mentioning Adam at all - Supernatural mythology is solid in some places, but it gets a bit wobbly in others, which is why we all tend to use fan theories to plug the gaps.
katschy liked this
fozmeadows posted this